The Problem with Youtube Coaching…

You’ve Watched the Videos. You’re Still Stuck.

You’ve watched hours of disc golf form content on YouTube, and you haven’t gotten any better.

If that’s you, I don’t think it’s necessarily because you’re lazy or incapable. I think it’s because the system you’re learning from is broken for long-term development.

That’s not an attack on creators (that’d be awfully hypocritical). It’s a structural issue.

Why Disc Golf YouTube Looks the Way It Does

Disc golf YouTube is dominated by backhand distance, and there are two main reasons for that.

First, distance gets clicks. If you put “distance” in a title or thumbnail, or you promise someone 50 or 100 more feet, that video is going to get views. If you’re trying to make a living doing this it’s totally understandable why a creator would be tempted to develop that content creating practice.

Second, distance is what most coaches are comfortable teaching. You usually teach what you know first. That’s normal.

Those two things create a feedback loop.
You watch distance videos. YouTube notices. Then it shows you more distance videos.

In the meantime, if someone posts a video on balance, approach shots, or posture, YouTube probably doesn’t show you that. You miss it.

Over time, your feed becomes distorted. It becomes distance, distance, distance.

And eventually, you start thinking disc golf is only about distance.

Distance Was a Necessary Starting Point

Now, this isn’t a complaint about starting with distance. It was a necessary phase (not a lifestyle 😛).

Distance is a great place to start for a lot of players.

The backhand is an incredibly complex athletic motion. It’s the most complex movement I’ve ever coached…and I thought teaching the tennis serve was hard.

Distance is also a powerful diagnostic tool.
When you throw a control shot, inefficiencies can hide.
When you throw for max distance, they can’t.

If your brace is off, your timing is bad, or your sequencing is broken, you’ll see it immediately when you try to throw far.

Distance also vastly improves quality of life on the course.

If there’s a 300-foot hole and your max distance is 300 feet, you’re probably throwing an understable disc and hyzer-flipping it. It has to move through multiple angles just to reach the basket. That’s a low-percentage play. Add a headwind, and you may not even get there.

Now imagine that same hole with 400 feet of power. You can throw a stable or overstable disc on a simple hyzer the entire way. One angle and the disc wants to finish One Direction. That’s a much higher percentage play. 

Players who get to choose higher-percentage plays more often score better.
In that way, distance sets the ceiling for how consistently you can score.

The Coaching Realization: Depth Has a Limit

For a long time, we went deep on the distance end of the spectrum.

And through coaching, something became very clear:

There are only a few key positions in good backhand form but there are an infinite number of ways players manage to break them.

On YouTube, that turns into symptom videos.

You teach the key position.
Then you make videos about what ruins it.

One player ruins their brace with forward drift.
Another with poor posture.
Another with over-rotation.

Now you’ve got videos titled “This Is Ruining Your Brace.”

Here’s the problem: not everyone has the same problems.

Students don’t know what to ignore.

YouTube is equally unskilled at showing things in the right order.

If I make a video on posture, which might be the most important piece for someone’s brace, that video probably won’t get shown to most people. Posture isn’t sexy. Distance is.

YouTube struggles with order, structure, and long-term development.

And at some point, you hit the ceiling of how deep The Algorithm Overlord allows you to go.

Depth vs Width

For those reasons, for Overthrow, depth alone isn’t the answer anymore.

If your disc golf game is a puzzle, depth is studying a single piece. You can learn everything about that piece. But if that’s all you study, do you really understand it?

Width is studying the box.

Depth teaches detail.
Width teaches context.

Distance without control is incomplete.
Accuracy without distance is limiting.

Disc golf lives between those extremes, and good players know how to move along that spectrum. You’re not choosing distance or accuracy you’re blending them shot by shot.

Real development requires oscillating.

You zoom in.
You zoom out.
You study pieces.
You study how they fit together.

That’s how your body learns how everything connects.

Reframing the Role of YouTube

YouTube is excellent at isolated ideas, perspective, and awareness.

It is absolutely horrid at structure and long-term development.

Depth needs something else.

It needs private coaching (this will always be king).
Or it needs structured courses (the more affordable prince).

Not because YouTube is bad but because it’s not built for the organization players need for long-term development.

Improvement requires sequence.

What This Means for You

As a player, your practice needs to span the spectrum.

Yes, work on distance (did I even need to tell you).

But also work on approach shots.
Work on control.
Work across all ranges and let your body organize those relationships over time.

If you only zoom in, you’ll miss the bigger picture.

If you only zoom out, you’ll lack precision.

You need both.

Why We Built the Academy

This is exactly why we built Overthrow Academy.

YouTube introduces ideas.
The Academy organizes them.

It creates order.
It eliminates indecision.
It answers “what comes next?”
It builds technique in sequence.

Not just more information.

Structured information.

Because knowledge is not development.

Intentional practice is.

‍